[Update 8/8/2025 – the day I published this post, the Attorney General issued a decision in Matter of Akhmedov that reconfirms detention of folks who entered unlawfully is under INA 236. So, for now the DHS memo is a dead letter.]

A secret memo. A new BIA decision. And a sweeping reinterpretation of who can be held without bond. If you or your client entered the U.S. without inspection, even years ago, this shift could mean indefinite detention without access to a judge.

A Radical New Rule, Quietly Implemented

On July 8, 2025, ICE officers across the country received a memo from DHS titled “Interim Guidance Regarding Detention Authority for Applicants for Admission.” Without public notice, rulemaking, or a published BIA decision, the memo instructs that any noncitizen who has not been admitted into the United States is subject to mandatory detention under INA § 235(b), with no eligibility for bond hearings under § 236(a).

This policy shift expands the reasoning in Matter of Q. Li, a May 2025 BIA decision that held individuals apprehended shortly after unlawful entry and processed for credible fear interviews are not entitled to a bond hearing (even years later) because they are actually applicants for admission (even if they didn’t apply for admission). But this memo goes even further. It asserts that anyone present without admission, even those who were never processed for credible fear interviews, is now considered an “applicant for admission” subject to § 235 detention.

The result? For a vast category of immigrants in detention, release on bond is no longer available.

What Happened in Matter of Q. Li?

In Matter of Q. Li, 28 I&N Dec. 728 (BIA 2025), the BIA held that individuals arrested shortly after entering the U.S. without inspection, regardless of whether they were apprehended at a port of entry, are to be treated as “arriving aliens.” Because arriving aliens are subject to mandatory detention under INA § 235(b), the BIA concluded that immigration judges lack jurisdiction to release them on bond under § 236(a).

Ms. Q. Li, a native of China, had crossed the U.S.-Mexico border in 2022 and was arrested within 100 yards of the border. Although she was initially released on parole and complied with all check-ins, DHS later revoked her parole and re-detained her. She asked for a bond hearing. The IJ denied jurisdiction, and the BIA affirmed.

The Memo: Bond Is Off the Table for All “Applicants for Admission”

The July 8 memo from DHS builds directly on Q. Li, but removes even more safeguards. It declares that all applicants for admission must be detained under § 235(b), and that ICE officers must not issue I-286 bond forms for them. Under this interpretation:

  • Immigration judges lack bond jurisdiction, even in § 240 proceedings.
  • Individuals previously released on bond or recognizance can be re-detained.
  • Only DHS parole under INA § 212(d)(5) remains as a possible path to release.

The memo also asserts that this change was made “in coordination with the Department of Justice.” But that raises a serious concern.

When the Prosecutor and the Judge Are on the Same Team

In immigration court, DOJ controls the judges. DHS is the prosecutor. The idea that these two entities are “coordinating” their interpretation of detention authority, not in litigation, but behind closed doors, raises serious due process concerns. The legitimacy of the immigration court system depends on the independence of its adjudicators. When the judge and the prosecutor align on how the law should be interpreted, that independence is deeply compromised.

Legal Framework: What the Terms Actually Mean

To understand how these changes are being justified—and why they’re so sweeping, it’s crucial to distinguish between similar-sounding legal terms.

“Arriving Alien”

A term of art defined in 8 C.F.R. § 1001.1(q). It refers only to:

“An applicant for admission coming or attempting to come into the United States at a port-of-entry, or an alien interdicted in international or United States waters.”

It does not include most people who cross rivers or deserts between ports. Nor does it automatically include someone paroled in and then placed in § 240 proceedings. Courts have long disputed whether someone can remain an “arriving alien” after parole.

Importantly, arriving aliens have never been eligible for bond before an IJ. But Q. Li and the memo sidestep this definition.

“Aliens Who Arrive” vs. “Applicants for Admission”

In Matter of Q. Li, the BIA focused on the statutory language in INA § 235(a)(1):

“an alien who arrives in the United States, whether or not at a designated port of arrival.”

The BIA cited Matter of M-D-C-V- to extend “arriving” to anyone apprehended just after entry, even if they crossed between ports. The ruling effectively classifies them as detained applicants for admission.

The July 8 memo takes that logic even further. It declares that anyone not admitted—even years after an unlawful entry—is an applicant for admission and must be detained under § 235(b).

This redefinition ignores whether the person was apprehended while “arriving.” Instead, it focuses solely on their admission status—meaning that even longtime residents who entered without inspection decades ago are swept in. This also largely ignores the Supreme Court’s decision in Jennings v. Rodriguez.

Why This Isn’t Just Theoretical: Real Cases, Real Impact

OPLA attorneys are now appearing in bond hearings and arguing, based on this memo, that anyone who entered unlawfully is an applicant for admission and therefore is never eligible for a bond. They’re arguing this even for people previously granted bonds.

In some cases, they’ve filed Form I-261s to change the charges mid-case, attempting to bring previously bond-eligible respondents under the new § 235-only interpretation.

Final Thoughts: Detained by Definition

The July 8 memo and Matter of Q. Li reflect a sweeping attempt by DHS to redefine its detention authority using classification alone. If someone was never admitted, they are now, by definition, detainable without a hearing. That’s not just a change in legal interpretation; it’s a change in the foundational assumptions about due process and liberty in the immigration system.

And it’s happening without a single new law, regulation, or public debate.

If you or someone you know has been denied bond, re-detained, or told there is no right to a hearing, contact an experienced immigration attorney immediately.